نوع مقاله : نقد و بررسی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسنده English
This discussion re-examines the evidence in “Did Market Closure Stabilize or Delay the Market? Price Discovery and Volatility Resilience in the Tehran Stock Exchange under Geopolitical Shock,” published in Journal of Applied Economics Studies in Iran (Vol. 15, No. 59), which analyzes the Tehran Stock Exchange around its 80-day equity-market suspension and its reopening on 19 May 2026, using a broad-market proxy and the TSETMC equal-weight index. The study reports cumulative nominal returns of 37.33% and 41.90% over the first twenty sessions, compares them with historical and forecast-based benchmarks, and assesses how long return variability takes to normalize. This discussion recognizes the value of documenting an exceptional episode and notes that the study itself cautions against a causal reading. It argues, however, that the study’s title question, together with the labels “price discovery,” “counterfactual,” and “volatility resilience,” promises more than the evidence can deliver. First, post-reopening repricing, particularly under a controlled reopening, is not price discovery. Second, deviations from pre-event forecasts are not causal effects without a credible no-closure counterfactual that separates the suspension from the concurrent geopolitical conflict and reopening restrictions. Third, normalization of return magnitude is threshold-dependent and says little about liquidity, market depth, or the capacity to absorb shocks. The reported results are best read as descriptive evidence on post-reopening return behavior. Whether closure stabilized or delayed the market remains open; the discussion outlines the data and designs needed to answer it.
کلیدواژهها English